Book mini-review thread

Anime Games Films Etc
Post Reply
User avatar
SonicTempest
Posts too much
Posts:3409
Joined:Wed May 04, 2005 14:26
A.K.A.:>8|
Currently Playing:Dark Souls II
XBL:SonicTempest84
PSN:SonicTempest
Location:Seattle, WA
Contact:
Book mini-review thread

Post by SonicTempest » Wed Jul 27, 2005 14:15

Comics do not count :P

Apart from the ubiquitous Harry Potter, I've been doing some other, more serious reading recently. Note: This is non-fiction, so please don't complain if you can't understand WTF I'm talking about :P

The Return of Depression Economics by Paul Krugman
Globalization and its Discontents by Joseph Stiglitz

The two books are by different authors, but I list them together because they share similar theses. Krugman is an economist from Princeton University who has a regular column in the New York Times, while Stiglitz is another economist who has worked in the Council of Economic Advisors as well as the World Bank. Both share similar views about the current state of world economic management.

Krugman's book is mainly about the financial crisis that enveloped Asia in 1997. It is largely an essay on how several decades of largely uninterrupted prosperity have mistakenly convinced people that the business cycle is dead. Krugman's main argument is that the Asian crisis has proven more than ever that depressions are as likely as they were 70 years ago.

Krugman makes another, secondary point later into his book, one which segues nicely into Stiglitz' main argument. He notes that the IMF totally mismanaged the crises that erupted in East Asia, Russia and elsewhere, by imposing policies that ran contrary to everything that we have learned from dealing with crises (e.g. raising interest rates in the face of a demand slump, doing away with financial market regulations which increases vulnerability to speculative attacks, etc)

Stiglitz takes this point and runs with it for the entirety of his book. Having worked with the World Bank, the IMF and the US Treasury Department during his career, Stiglitz professes to be shocked at their policy prescriptions that appear to blindly follow the textbook prescriptions for a free market economy without proper theoretical backing or consideration for the norms of particular countries. He notes, rather correctly, I would imagine, the irony that an institution founded on the principle of correcting imperfections in the market (the IMF) is now a zealous champion of markets while deeply distrustful of intervention of any kind (in spite of it intervening in many such cases to prop up overvalued currencies and the like).

Krugman's tract is broad-based, and covers a wide range of issues, from the Tequila crisis in Mexico, to Latin American debt/foreign exchange crises, to Japan's stagnation, to the East Asian Financial Crisis. His book makes for easy reading even for non-economists, due to its simple language and use of simple models to explain basic macroeconomic principles.

Stiglitz' book is lengthier, more focused on the titular issue (how globalisation has failed to live up to its promise) but is still quite eminently readable. The text does not devolve into jargon, but does expect you to have some basic knowledge of how markets work.

As for the strength of their arguments, I personally found Krugman's reasoning and argument to be convincing, but Stiglitz is a little too negative a lot of the time, often making it seem as if the international financial institutions can do no good, which is a point of view that my centrist outlook is not very willing to believe. His basic argument, though, is sound, and he makes a real case for the substantial reform of those institutions so that the fruits of globalisation may be shared by all.

Both books are recommended for anyone interested in the economic issues of our day.
Last edited by SonicTempest on Wed Aug 23, 2006 08:35, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
Blake B
More power! ...25%
More power! ...25%
Posts:211
Joined:Fri Jul 22, 2005 05:07
A.K.A.:Turned ON
Location:Somewhere in Florida
Contact:

Post by Blake B » Tue Aug 30, 2005 22:18

Okay............here's my review of a book i've read.....

"Tears Of A Tiger"
-By Sharon Draper

First off, the book starts off with some high school buddies, that are on the basketball team of their school, drinkin' and drivin', celebrating their victory in tonite's game. They get into this really bad car accident, killing the driver's best friend during the impact of the crash. Andy, who was the driver of one of the cars that was involed into the accident, starts to feel all guilty and blames himself for causing his best friend to die. Becoming angry and majorly depressed inside, his life is turned upside down. (Wait a minute, i'm doing a summary, not a review!!!!)

This book is something i'm sure alot of people can relate to, you can even relate a whole lot to the characters in the story!!! Although the book is kinda short (between 100-300 pages), it's better than some of the 500-100 pages books out there. In some parts of the book, they have some characters from the book opinions on what's going on (through journal entries and things like that), which brings you closer to the story and makes you wonders what's going to happen next. This book also covers racism and society, which makes the book very interesting......as for someone who's been in alot of racist encounters, i found this book to be better than i've expected it to be. With alot of humor put in, as well as seriousness into it, it becomes an spectactular, as well as entertaining story about Andy and his personal issues. With the dramatic twist ending (The ending will shock you and sorta make you sad...), you will really want to know what happens after the book ends. I recomend this book to anyone that knows how to read..........it's that good.


P.S. I shed alot of tears during the reading of this book. Next, i'm reviewing "The catcher in the rye", whenever i get done reading it.

User avatar
SonicTempest
Posts too much
Posts:3409
Joined:Wed May 04, 2005 14:26
A.K.A.:>8|
Currently Playing:Dark Souls II
XBL:SonicTempest84
PSN:SonicTempest
Location:Seattle, WA
Contact:

Post by SonicTempest » Wed Aug 23, 2006 08:33

The World is Flat: A Brief History of the Globalized World in the 21st Century
by Thomas L. Friedman

It was with rather prophetic timing that I began reading The World is Flat...I was on my way to India for an internship with Infosys, the very company who gave Thomas Friedman, the respected New York Times columnist, the spark to write this particular book. One phrase from the Infosys CEO, Nandan Nilekani, "The playing field is being leveled," spurred Friedman to embark on a journey to discover how the world became flat, and the implications of its flatness.

In essence, this is a book about the flattening of the world - not literally, but in many figurative senses. It takes on a new generation of globalizing forces such as offshoring, outsourcing and global supply-chain management and analyses their impact - both positive and negative - around the world. And I must say it does a very good job of presenting the issues at hand clearly, coherently and understandably - even for the layman. Friedman does a good job of demystifying and rationalizing the outsourcing boom, making things like supply chain management and the like comprehensible to the average reader.

He doesn't stop at covering the economic aspects of the issue either. Social and geopolitical aspects are covered in detail as well, such as how America needs to adjust socially and geopolitically to survive in the flat world. I find he takes a very balanced point of view - he recognises that things such as outsourcing and offshoring are inevitable in a free market, but he doesn't disregard the effect it has on those workers whose jobs are outsourced. He even manages to link the flat world to that ever-present spectre looming over our heads - global terrorism and networks such as al-Qaeda.

I found The World is Flat to be a fascinating and a very educational book. Everyone who is going to work, or even live in the flat world absolutely needs to read this book to prepare themselves for the changes to come.

Strongly recommended.

User avatar
Eczema
MOAR
Posts:955
Joined:Mon May 09, 2005 08:04
A.K.A.:Turned ON
Location:Looking at porn....

Post by Eczema » Wed Aug 23, 2006 09:51

I have read some of Krugman's work. It was about sweatshops and it seemed very biased and emotive without much referencing and citations.

Do you have to read this books for university or something? It is weird for someone to read about globalization unless they have to (like me).

User avatar
SonicTempest
Posts too much
Posts:3409
Joined:Wed May 04, 2005 14:26
A.K.A.:>8|
Currently Playing:Dark Souls II
XBL:SonicTempest84
PSN:SonicTempest
Location:Seattle, WA
Contact:

Post by SonicTempest » Sat Sep 02, 2006 02:03

I read them because I want to, not because of class or anything. Is it that hard to believe? :P

And I'm pretty sure Krugman cites his sources - he's an academic, after all...and an economist, at that. I haven't found anything in his readings that I could conceivably prove wrong.

Post Reply